An evaluation of core knowledge curriculum in charter schools

Programs:

Core Knowledge curriculum (the basis for Amplify CKLA)

State:

Colorado

Grade level:

Kindergarten (entry) and grades 3–6 (measured outcomes)

Demographics: 

  • Nine Core Knowledge charter schools across six school districts in the Denver, Colorado, area 
  • 14 kindergarten lotteries conducted
  • 2,360 student applicants across all lotteries
  • 688 students selected for the treatment group
  • Study population predominantly from middle- and high-income school districts, with one school representing a low-income district

Study year:

Published 2023

Overview

Researchers from the University of Virginia, University of Notre Dame, and Auburn University conducted an experimental evaluation of the Core Knowledge curriculum across nine charter schools in the Denver, Colorado, area. Using 14 kindergarten lotteries, a treatment group of 688 students was formed. Non-winners served as the comparison group, with state achievement data collected from grades 3–6.

Students in the Core Knowledge group significantly outperformed the comparison group on state reading tests with a Treatment on the Treated (TOT) effect size of 0.473, equating to approximately 16 cumulative percentile points. A Core Knowledge charter school serving a low-income district produced even stronger results, with effect sizes of 1.299 in ELA and 0.997 in mathematics, eliminating achievement gaps in all measured subjects.

Key takeaways

  • Researchers conducted a longitudinal study using a kindergarten lottery design in the Denver area to assess the long-term impact of Core Knowledge on student reading achievement.
  • Students who received Core Knowledge instruction significantly outperformed the comparison group on state reading tests, with a statistically significant effect size of 0.473.  Cumulative reading gains, measured across grades 3–6, were approximately 16 percentile points, and income-based achievement gaps were eliminated.
  • Students in the low-income school in the study experienced the largest gains, with an effect size of 1.299 in ELA and 0.997 in mathematics, eliminating income-based achievement gaps across all measured subjects for grades 3–6.
“To put this into perspective… national student gains [in reading] similar to the gains realized in this intervention would place the U.S. among the top five countries.”

Daniel Willingham, Ph.D., University of Virginia